Extreme Would You Rather Questions: 94 Wild but Harmless Picks for Kids and Families
November 2026 · 94 questions
The best extreme would you rather questions are huge, wild and harmless: would you rather ride the tallest roller coaster or the fastest, live in a treehouse or a lighthouse, or jump 100 feet high or run 100 miles an hour? This page has 14 extreme two-choice cards and 80 more questions, all clean and kid-friendly. There’s nothing scary or gross, so they’re a good fit for a family party on New Year’s Eve, Thursday, December 31, or any night.
Tap through the deck for a quick round, or read the cards aloud and have everyone vote with a thumbs up or down.
🎮 Play this list
Would you rather…
OR
Opens the full game with all 94 questions from this page and the real vote results.
Game 1: The extreme but harmless deck
Go big and silly. The goal is the wildest choices that are still totally safe.
Would you rather ride the tallest roller coaster in the world or ride the fastest roller coaster in the world?
Would you rather live in a treehouse or live in a lighthouse?
Would you rather have snow every day or have sunshine every day?
Would you rather jump 100 feet high or run 100 miles an hour?
Would you rather have a pet dragon the size of a cat or have a cat the size of a dragon?
Would you rather eat only breakfast foods forever or eat only dinner foods forever?
Would you rather have a snowman that walks and talks or have a robot that does your chores?
Would you rather slide down a mile-long slide or zip-line across a canyon?
Would you rather be the size of an ant for a day or be the size of a giant for a day?
Would you rather have a bouncy house for a floor or have a slide instead of stairs?
Would you rather count down from 1,000 out loud or say the alphabet backward ten times?
Would you rather have a hundred balloons or have a hundred bubbles?
Would you rather live inside a snow globe or live inside a giant bubble?
Would you rather race a cheetah on a bike or race a dolphin in a boat?
80 more extreme would you rather questions
Pick a section for your crowd. Every question is clean and family-friendly, with no gore, no danger and nothing gross beyond silly.
Extreme sizes, speeds and powers
Would you rather be able to fly at the speed of sound or be able to breathe underwater at the bottom of the ocean?
Would you rather be ten feet tall or be ten inches tall?
Would you rather have arms that stretch ten feet or have legs that jump ten feet?
Would you rather be able to freeze time for a minute or be able to rewind time by a minute?
Would you rather have super strength for a day or have super speed for a day?
Would you rather be able to talk to every animal or be able to understand every language?
Would you rather have a magic backpack that holds anything or have a magic bicycle that flies?
Would you rather be invisible for an hour or be able to teleport once a day?
Would you rather have the world’s loudest laugh or have the world’s tallest hair?
Would you rather run on the surface of water or walk on walls like a spider?
Extreme adventures
Would you rather climb the highest mountain in the world or dive to the deepest part of the ocean?
Would you rather spend a week on a desert island or spend a week at the North Pole?
Would you rather explore a cave full of crystals or explore a rainforest full of butterflies?
Would you rather ride a hot-air balloon around the world or sail a pirate ship around the world?
Would you rather live on the moon for a year or live on a space station for a year?
Would you rather go on a safari with a camera or go on a deep-sea dive in a submarine?
Would you rather sleep in an igloo or sleep in a treehouse?
Would you rather cross a rope bridge over a canyon or slide down a giant sand dune?
Would you rather travel back in time to meet dinosaurs or travel forward in time 100 years?
Would you rather take a road trip across the whole country or take a boat trip across the whole ocean?
Extreme food (all safe and yummy)
Would you rather eat a pizza as big as a car or eat a cookie as big as a table?
Would you rather eat a hundred pancakes in a day or eat a hundred tacos in a day?
Would you rather have a lifetime supply of ice cream or have a lifetime supply of pizza?
Would you rather eat only sweet foods for a month or eat only salty foods for a month?
Would you rather have a chocolate fountain in your house or have a popcorn machine in your house?
Would you rather live on a farm where food grows on trees or live in a candy-colored town?
Would you rather never eat a hot meal again or never eat a cold meal again?
Would you rather have a cake every day for breakfast or have soup every day for dessert?
Would you rather eat a giant pretzel or eat a giant waffle?
Would you rather have a hot cocoa river or have a lemonade lake?
Extreme weather and winter
Would you rather have a snow day every week or have a beach day every week?
Would you rather build the biggest snow fort ever or build the biggest sandcastle ever?
Would you rather live where it’s winter all year or live where it’s summer all year?
Would you rather be snowed in for a week with your family or be snowed in for a week with your friends?
Would you rather go sledding down a giant hill or go ice skating on a frozen lake?
Would you rather walk through the world’s biggest snowstorm or watch the world’s biggest thunderstorm from indoors?
Would you rather see the northern lights or see a total solar eclipse?
Would you rather have it rain candy or have it snow marshmallows?
Would you rather have a snowball that never melts or have a rainbow that follows you?
Would you rather wake up to ten feet of snow or wake up to a perfectly sunny day?
Extreme at school and at home
Would you rather have no homework for a year or have no tests for a year?
Would you rather have a school with a water slide or have a school with a roller coaster?
Would you rather never lose your keys or never lose your phone?
Would you rather have a house with a secret room or have a house with a slide?
Would you rather clean the whole house in one minute or do the dishes in one second?
Would you rather have a bedroom that’s a treehouse or have a bedroom that’s a spaceship?
Would you rather have a library in your house or have a game room in your house?
Would you rather sleep in a bed made of clouds or sleep in a hammock under the stars?
Would you rather be the best at every sport or be the best at every instrument?
Would you rather have a talking pet or have a pet that does tricks?
New Year’s Eve extreme
Would you rather stay up until the countdown every year or wake up early for every sunrise?
Would you rather count down from 100 with the whole family or count down from 10 with the whole street?
Would you rather make ten resolutions or make one very big resolution?
Would you rather watch a giant fireworks show or watch a giant light show?
Would you rather have a New Year’s party that lasts three days or have three parties in one night?
Would you rather make the loudest noise at midnight or make the biggest pile of confetti?
Would you rather have a midnight snack buffet or have a midnight dance party?
Would you rather wear a giant paper party hat or wear a hundred paper stars?
Would you rather have a time capsule you open in ten years or have a time capsule you open in 50 years?
Would you rather start the New Year in a snowy cabin or start the New Year on a warm beach?
Extreme animals and nature
Would you rather have a pet elephant or have a pet giraffe?
Would you rather ride a dolphin or ride a friendly whale?
Would you rather be able to fly like a bird or be able to swim like a fish?
Would you rather have a pet unicorn or have a pet phoenix?
Would you rather live in a forest with talking trees or live in a sea with talking fish?
Would you rather have the world’s biggest garden or have the world’s biggest aquarium?
Would you rather walk through a field of a million sunflowers or walk through a forest of giant redwoods?
Would you rather camp inside a giant hollow tree or camp on a floating island?
Would you rather hug the fluffiest polar bear cub or hug the fluffiest baby penguin?
Would you rather have a parrot that tells jokes or have a puppy that does backflips?
Extreme silly
Would you rather sneeze glitter or hiccup bubbles?
Would you rather have hair that changes color with your mood or have shoes that play music when you walk?
Would you rather wear a cape every day or wear a crown every day?
Would you rather have a talking toaster or have a dancing vacuum?
Would you rather burp the alphabet or hum every time you walk?
Would you rather have a rubber duck army or have a marshmallow army?
Would you rather giggle every time you speak or whisper every time you shout?
Would you rather have a hat that floats above your head or have a scarf that never ends?
Would you rather always walk in slow motion or always talk in a funny voice?
Would you rather have pajamas for every day of the year or have a pillow fort in every room?
How to play extreme would you rather
Read a question aloud, then count to three.
Everyone votes at once by holding up one finger for the first choice and two for the second.
Pick one person on each side to explain in 20 seconds.
Vote again to see who switched.
Extreme would you rather for a New Year’s Eve party
New Year’s Eve falls on Thursday, December 31, 2026. For a family party, play a round or two before the countdown and save the dramatic questions for the end of the night. Serve sparkling cider or cocoa, and keep a pile of confetti handy for the new year. See our New Year’s games and New Year’s would you rather for more.
Make it extra fun
Add a “rate it” round. Everyone gives each choice a score from 1 to 10 before voting.
Act it out. Let a volunteer show what their pick would look like.
Keep the peace. If someone isn’t comfortable with a question, they can pass.
Mix in cozy cards. A few calm questions between big ones keep younger kids at ease.
Frequently asked questions
What are some extreme would you rather questions?
Would you rather ride the tallest roller coaster or the fastest? Be ten feet tall or ten inches tall? Live in a treehouse or a lighthouse? Have snow every day or sunshine every day?
Are these questions kid-friendly?
Yes. Every question is clean: big, silly and imaginative, with nothing violent, scary or gross.
Would you rather ride the tallest roller coaster or the fastest one? Be ten feet tall or ten inches tall? Live in a treehouse or a lighthouse? Jump 100 feet high or run 100 miles an hour?
What are extreme would you rather questions for kids?
Wild but harmless picks work best: a pet dragon the size of a cat or a cat the size of a dragon, a slide instead of stairs, a hundred pancakes in a day or a snow day every week.
Are there clean extreme would you rather questions?
Yes. Every question on this page is clean: big and silly, with no gore, danger or gross-out choices.
What are good extreme questions for a New Year's Eve party?
Try countdown questions, midnight snack and dance party picks, confetti and time capsule questions and starting the new year in a snowy cabin or on a warm beach.
How do you play extreme would you rather?
Read a question, count to three, vote with one finger or two, then let one person on each side explain in 20 seconds. Vote again to see who switched.
How are these different from hard or crazy questions?
Extreme questions are about huge sizes, speeds and adventures, with no moral dilemmas. The hardest questions are tougher to choose between, and the crazy ones are goofier.