Baby Shower Would You Rather: 50 Questions for Your Guests

October 2026  ·  50 questions

Baby shower would you rather is a ready-to-play game: read a question about baby life or parenting, guests pick a side, and the best stories win the room. All 50 questions are below, followed by simple game rules, ways to run it at any size of shower and tips for making printable cards.

This game is a favorite with hosts because it needs almost no setup, works with any number of guests and gets everyone talking, from the grandmother who raised five kids to the friend who has never changed a diaper. The questions are sweet, a little silly and completely family-friendly, so they fit a church hall shower, a backyard sprinkle, a coed party or a cozy virtual gathering.

The 50 Baby Shower Would You Rather Questions

Diapers, Bottles and Baby Basics

• Would you rather change ten diapers in a row, or do one middle-of-the-night feeding every night for a week?
• Would you rather have a baby who only naps in the car, or one who only naps while being held?
• Would you rather give a squirmy baby a bath, or clip a sleeping baby's tiny fingernails?
• Would you rather pack the diaper bag for a day trip, or assemble the crib from scratch?
• Would you rather have a baby who spits up on every outfit, or one who has a blowout at every outing?
• Would you rather wash bottles every day, or fold tiny laundry every day?
• Would you rather have a baby who wakes up at 5 a.m. happy, or at 8 a.m. grumpy?
• Would you rather install the car seat, or put together the stroller without instructions?
• Would you rather burp a baby for twenty minutes, or rock a baby to sleep for twenty minutes?
• Would you rather have a baby who loves every food, or a baby who sleeps through the night?

Sweet Baby Moments

• Would you rather hear the baby's first laugh, or see the baby's first steps?
• Would you rather the baby's first word be "mama," or "dada"?
• Would you rather have a baby with a full head of hair, or a perfectly bald, round little head?
• Would you rather get the sweetest newborn snuggles, or the biggest toddler hugs?
• Would you rather capture every moment in photos, or keep a handwritten baby journal?
• Would you rather have a baby who giggles at everything, or one who stares at you like they know a secret?
• Would you rather sing lullabies every night, or read the same bedtime story every night?
• Would you rather see the baby's first smile, or feel the baby's first grip on your finger?
• Would you rather have a baby who loves bath time, or one who loves tummy time?
• Would you rather have a baby with dimples, or a baby with big chubby cheeks?

Funny and Silly Picks

• Would you rather wear a baby bottle around your neck all day, or wear a bib to dinner?
• Would you rather sing every word you say for a day, like a lullaby, or speak only in baby talk for a day?
• Would you rather taste every jar of baby food on the shelf, or smell every diaper in the bag?
• Would you rather crawl everywhere for an hour, or drink only from a sippy cup for a day?
• Would you rather have to wear footie pajamas to work, or a onesie to the grocery store?
• Would you rather be followed around by a baby monitor that narrates your day, or a mobile that plays music when you sit down?
• Would you rather find a pacifier in every pocket you own, or a sock in every drawer?
• Would you rather walk on a floor covered in building blocks, or one covered in squeaky toys?
• Would you rather have a nursery theme of jungle animals, or a nursery theme of outer space?
• Would you rather be known as the family's best diaper changer, or its best baby whisperer?

Parenting Life

• Would you rather know the baby's name a year in advance, or pick it the day the baby arrives?
• Would you rather be surprised by the baby's gender at birth, or know early and plan everything?
• Would you rather have twins, or have two babies two years apart?
• Would you rather have grandparents living next door, or a trusted babysitter living next door?
• Would you rather have the baby's room perfectly decorated, or have a freezer full of ready meals?
• Would you rather be the fun parent, or the calm parent?
• Would you rather have a baby who looks just like you, or just like your partner?
• Would you rather plan every detail of the baby's first birthday party, or keep it small and simple?
• Would you rather go on a family road trip with a baby, or a family plane trip with a toddler?
• Would you rather have the baby's first holiday at home, or at a grandparent's house?
• Would you rather get a full night of sleep once a week, or a two-hour nap every single day?
• Would you rather teach the baby to swim, or teach the baby to ride a bike someday?

Guessing and Guest Picks

• Would you rather guess the baby's birth date, or the baby's birth weight?
• Would you rather give the parents a year of advice, or a year of home-cooked meals?
• Would you rather be the babysitter on date night, or the person who brings over dinner?
• Would you rather be the baby's favorite aunt or uncle, or the baby's favorite family friend?
• Would you rather knit the baby a blanket, or write the baby a letter to open on their 18th birthday?
• Would you rather share your best parenting tip, or your funniest parenting story?
• Would you rather read the baby a book at every visit, or sing the baby a song at every visit?
• Would you rather be there for the baby's first birthday, or the baby's first day of school?

How to Play Baby Shower Would You Rather

The classic rules are on our how to play would you rather page, but here is a simple version built for a shower.

What you need: the list above (or printed cards), two signs or colored paper squares for each guest, and an optional small prize.

The basic game:

• The host reads a question aloud.
• Each guest holds up a sign for the first or second option. Pink and blue paper, or any two colors that match the party, work nicely.
• The host picks one guest from each side to share a quick reason or story.
• Repeat for ten to fifteen questions.

The "match the parent" version: Before the shower, the parent-to-be secretly writes down their answer to each question. During the game, guests try to guess how the parent answered. Each correct match earns a point, and the guest with the most points wins a small prize. This version is a big hit because guests learn fun details about the parent-to-be along the way.

The "story round" version: Skip the scoring. After each question, invite anyone with a funny or sweet story to share it. This works best with groups full of experienced parents and grandparents who love to swap stories.

Choosing the Right Questions for Your Shower

Every shower crowd is different. Use this table to pick the best mix.

Shower style	Best sections	Number of questions	Tip
Classic afternoon shower	Sweet Baby Moments, Guessing and Guest Picks	10 to 12	Use the match-the-parent version
Coed or couples shower	Funny and Silly Picks, Parenting Life	12 to 15	Let both parents-to-be answer
Family-heavy shower	Diapers, Bottles and Baby Basics	10	Invite grandparents to share stories
Small, cozy sprinkle	Any mix	8 to 10	Go around the circle so everyone answers
Virtual shower	Sweet Baby Moments, Funny and Silly Picks	10	Use the chat box or hand signals for answers

Printable Card Tips

Printing questions on cards makes the game feel polished and lets guests take turns as the reader. Our printable would you rather cards page shows how to lay them out. A few shower-specific ideas:

• Match the party colors. Print cards on paper that matches the decorations, or add a simple border in the theme colors.
• Put them in a basket. Guests draw a card and read it to the group. It feels more like a game than a host reading from a list.
• Leave space for answers. If you are playing match-the-parent, add two small check boxes on each card so guests can mark their guess.
• Make a keepsake. Ask guests to write their answer and a short note on the back of a card. Put the cards in an envelope for the parents to read later.

Tips for Hosts

Play early. Run the game after guests arrive and settle in, but before gifts. It breaks the ice and gets people mingling.

Keep it short. Ten to fifteen questions is plenty. Baby shower would you rather is a warm-up, not the whole party, and you want energy left for gifts and cake.

Include everyone. Some guests may not have kids, and some may be new to the group. Questions in the Funny and Silly section work for anyone, so lean on those if your crowd is mixed.

Let the parent-to-be shine. Ask them to answer every question too. Guests love hearing their picks, and it keeps the focus on the guest of honor.

Have a backup plan for shy groups. If nobody wants to talk, switch to a simple show of hands and move quickly. Laughter usually builds after a few rounds.

Mistakes to Avoid

Questions that feel too personal. Topics like birth stories, body changes or family planning can make people uncomfortable. The list above avoids them, and it is best to keep it that way.

Going too long. A game that drags can lose the room. Watch for wandering eyes and wrap up a little early.

Making it a quiz. If the game feels like a test of parenting knowledge, guests without kids may feel left out. Keep it light.

Skipping the stories. The best part of baby shower would you rather is hearing why someone picked their answer. Always invite at least one reason per question.

Forgetting the prize. Even a tiny prize, like a candle or a homemade treat, adds friendly competition to the match-the-parent version.

Add a Few Custom Questions

Two or three questions written just for the parents-to-be can make the game feel personal. Think about their hobbies, the nursery theme or a family tradition, then turn it into a choice. If the parents love hiking, ask whether guests would rather take the baby on a first hike or a first trip to the beach. If the nursery has a woodland theme, ask whether the baby will grow up loving foxes or owls.

Keep custom questions warm and simple, and skip anything private. Slip them in near the end of the round so they land as a sweet surprise, and let the parent-to-be explain the story behind each one.

Want More Questions?

If guests are still asking for more, the would you rather questions for parents page has extra parenting picks for the experienced moms and dads in the room. For quick laughs, the funny would you rather questions list is full of silly options. And if the shower leans toward a long afternoon, our free would you rather game can keep the fun going on a phone or tablet.

📚 More from Would You Rather Online

See all articles →