Christmas Would You Rather for Teens: 51 Clean, Fun Questions for Teenagers

November 2026  ·  51 questions

Christmas would you rather for teens is a quick, clean party game with two-choice questions that teenagers actually want to answer, like “Would you rather get a snow day on Christmas Eve or an extra present under the tree?” Below are 51 of them in six groups: gifts, the family gathering, holiday food, winter break, silly picks and a few that go a little deeper. They work for teen Christmas parties, youth group nights, sleepovers and the long afternoon at Grandma’s.

Want to play right now? Tap a choice on the card below, then hit next.

When is Christmas 2026?

Christmas Eve is Thursday, December 24, 2026, and Christmas Day is Friday, December 25. That means a long weekend right at the start of winter break for most teens, which is a lot of family time. A good question deck helps.

51 Christmas would you rather questions for teenagers

Christmas morning and gift questions for teens

• Would you rather get a snow day on Christmas Eve or an extra present under the tree?
• Would you rather get one big gift you really wanted or ten small surprises?
• Would you rather open all your presents on Christmas Eve or wait until Christmas morning for everything?
• Would you rather get cash in a card or a gift someone clearly put real thought into?
• Would you rather wrap every present for the whole family or clean up all the wrapping paper after?
• Would you rather sleep in until noon on Christmas or be up at 6 a.m. with the little cousins?
• Would you rather have a stocking full of candy or a stocking full of tiny useful things like chargers and lip balm?
• Would you rather get the exact gift you asked for or a surprise you didn’t know you wanted?
• Would you rather give a homemade gift or spend your own money on a gift from a store?
• Would you rather open presents in matching family pajamas or in whatever you slept in?

Family gathering questions

• Would you rather sit at the kids’ table one more year or sit with the grown-ups and answer questions about school?
• Would you rather answer “So what are your plans after high school?” ten times or referee the little cousins all afternoon?
• Would you rather have your baby photos passed around to every guest or have your little cousin tell everyone your most embarrassing story?
• Would you rather be in charge of the holiday playlist or in charge of taking the family photo?
• Would you rather help cook Christmas dinner or do all the dishes after?
• Would you rather play a board game with your grandparents or teach them a video game?
• Would you rather host the whole family at your house or drive three hours to someone else’s?
• Would you rather go caroling around the neighborhood with your family or put on a talent show for them in the living room?
• Would you rather be the one who reads the Christmas story out loud or the one who hands out every present?
• Would you rather have a snowball fight with your cousins or a cookie-decorating contest with them?

Holiday food questions

• Would you rather eat only Christmas cookies for a whole day or only mashed potatoes and gravy?
• Would you rather have hot cocoa with a mountain of whipped cream or with a pile of marshmallows?
• Would you rather give up candy canes forever or give up gingerbread forever?
• Would you rather build a gingerbread house that collapses but is all yours or decorate a perfect kit someone else built?
• Would you rather have pancakes on Christmas morning or warm cinnamon rolls?
• Would you rather eat the last cookie on the plate or leave it out for Santa just in case?
• Would you rather have every holiday dish be extra cheesy or extra sweet?

Winter break questions

• Would you rather have a two-week winter break with no snow or a one-week break with three snow days?
• Would you rather binge holiday movies all break or be out with friends every day?
• Would you rather spend New Year’s Eve with your family or with a group of friends at someone’s house?
• Would you rather pick up a few extra shifts or babysitting jobs over break or have zero plans for two whole weeks?
• Would you rather go sledding all day or go ice skating all day?
• Would you rather have your phone die on Christmas morning or have your best friend not answer your texts all break?
• Would you rather stay up until 3 a.m. watching movies or wake up early for a quiet sunrise with cocoa?
• Would you rather spend break at a snowy cabin or at a warm beach?

Silly Christmas would you rather questions

• Would you rather be one of Santa’s elves for a year or one of his reindeer for a night?
• Would you rather have a talking snowman as your best friend or a gingerbread man who won’t stop running?
• Would you rather live in a snow globe town or inside a holiday movie?
• Would you rather hear Christmas songs every day all year or never hear one again?
• Would you rather trade places with Santa on Christmas Eve or with the Grinch for a day?
• Would you rather have the most decorated house on the block or the coziest little house on the block?
• Would you rather have a tree that sings every time you walk past or an ornament that tells your future?
• Would you rather be famous for the best ugly sweater or the best gift-wrapping skills?
• Would you rather have a group chat with Santa’s reindeer or with your favorite holiday movie characters?
• Would you rather have tinsel stuck in your hair all break or glitter on your face all break?

A little deeper

• Would you rather give one perfect gift or get one perfect gift?
• Would you rather keep one family tradition exactly the same forever or start a brand-new tradition this year?
• Would you rather spend Christmas with your whole extended family or with just your closest people?
• Would you rather remember every Christmas you’ve ever had or forget them all but have one perfect Christmas this year?
• Would you rather do a secret kind thing for a neighbor or volunteer with your friends for a day?
• Would you rather send one message to your future self about this Christmas or get one message from your past self?

How to play would you rather with teens (without the cringe)

Here’s the honest truth: teens will play, as long as it doesn’t feel like a forced family activity. A few things help a lot.

• Let a teen run it. Hand the phone or the card deck to one of them and let them pick the questions. It instantly feels less like homework.
• No speeches. Everyone picks, and anyone who wants to explain can. Nobody has to.
• Keep it moving. Ten quick questions beat one long debate. If a question flops, skip it.
• Mix the generations on purpose. Teens love hearing what Grandpa picks for “sleep in until noon or be up at 6 a.m. with the cousins.” Spoiler: he usually picks 6 a.m.
• Use phones, not against them. Play from the card above on one phone and pass it around. Everyone’s already holding one anyway.

Teen Christmas party game ideas using these questions

Youth group Christmas would you rather

For a youth group Christmas party, start with the silly section to warm everyone up, move into the family and winter break questions, and end with “A little deeper.” Those last few open up easy conversations about gratitude, traditions and giving, without anyone having to share more than they want to. The fun activities for youth groups page has more ideas for the rest of the night.

More questions for teens and the whole family

If you want more year-round picks, the would you rather questions for teens list is the big one, and the funny questions for teenagers are great when you just want laughs. Got younger kids at the party too? Mix in a few from the Christmas would you rather for kids deck, and the grown-ups can grab some from the Christmas questions for adults.

What most people get wrong

Picking questions that are “for teens” but really written by a grown-up guessing what teens like. Teens can smell that a mile away. Keep the questions about real things in their December: sleeping in, winter break plans, cousins, phones, cocoa and the classic “so what are your plans after high school?” question. And keep it kind: pick questions anyone at the table can answer. Everyone has more fun when nobody’s put on the spot. When you’re ready for more, play the full Would You Rather game.

📚 More from Would You Rather Online

See all articles →